Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Menu
We are a pre-order only establishment. At least 36 hours notice for orders. We make all products from scratch per order. Prices may fluctuate on flavor & design complexity.
CUPCAKE FLAVORS
36 hour notice for all orders! Choose 6 or 12 per flavor. Optional two flavors per dozen.
Almond Joy®
Chocolate cake with coconut cream filling topped with almond buttercream
$20.00
Apple Cider
Apple cider cake topped with spiced apple buttercream and cinnamon sugar
$20.00
Apple Cinnamon
Apple cinnamon cake topped with cinnamon buttercream
$20.00
Apple Pumpkin **SEASONAL
Pumpkin spice cake topped with apple pie filling and cinnamon whipped cream **SEASONAL SEPT-NOV
$21.00
Apple Pie **SEASONAL ONLY**
Spiced vanilla cake topped with apple filling and cinnamon whipped cream drizzled with caramel AVAILABLE SEPT-NOV
$21.00
BAKLAVA
Vanilla honey cake filled with sweetened pecans and walnuts topped with honey cinnamon frosting and filo dough
$24.00
Banana Nutella
Fresh banana cake with honey cinnamon cream cheese frosting topped with Nutella * refrigeration needed
$44.00
Blueberry Pie
Blueberry vanilla cake with blueberry filling topped with whipped cream and graham crackers *refrigeration needed
$21.00
Butter Finger candy bar
Chocolate cake topped with peanut butter crunch buttercream
$20.00
Caramel Apple
Apple cake topped with apple pie filling and caramel
$21.00
Caramel Macchiato
Mocha cake with whipped cream espresso frosting topped with a caramel drizzle *refrigeration needed
$20.00
Candy Cane
Peppermint cupcakes topped with a creamy peppermint frosting **Seasonal Nov-Jan
$21.00
Candy Corn
Vanilla cake topped with honey buttercream
$20.00
Carrot Cake
Carrot cake with cream cheese frosting topped with pecans PER DOZEN ONLY *refrigeration needed
$42.00
Cereal
any cereal flavored cake and cereal milk frosting
$20.00
Chocolate Candy
M & M® candy filled cake with vanilla frosting
$19.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Chocolate cake filled with edible cookie dough with cookie dough buttercream
$21.00
Chocolate Covered Cherry
Chocolate cake filled with cherry preserves topped with cherry buttercream frosting
$22.00
Chocolate Cannoli
Vanilla cinnamon cake filled and topped with cannoli cream and chocolate chips DOZEN ONLY
$46.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
Chocolate cake with peanut butter filling topped with chocolate whipped frosting and pretzels
$21.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Chocolate cake with Peanut butter frosting
$20.00
Cinnamon Roll
Cinnamon swirl cake topped with icing and cinnamon sugar frosting
$21.00
Circus Animal Cookie
Vanilla cake filled with cookie crumb cheesecake, topped with rainbow sprinkle frosting
$22.00
Coffee Toffee
Vanilla cake topped with coffee buttercream and toffee bits
$20.00
Cookie Butter
Vanilla cake topped with biscoff whipped frosting and cookie butter swirl
$21.00
Cookies and Cream
Chocolate cake with oreo cookies and cookies and cream whipped frosting
$21.00
Cotton Candy
Cotton candy flavored vanilla cake with blue & pink frosting topped with real cotton candy
$21.00
Crunch bar
Vanilla cake topped with chocolate crispy buttercream
$20.00
Dark Chocolate Orange
Dark chocolate cake infused with fresh oranges topped with chocolate orange frosting
$21.00
Double chocolate
Chocolate cake topped with chocolate whipped cream. *refrigeration needed
$21.00
Espresso
Espresso soaked cake topped with coffee whipped cream *refrigeration needed
$21.00
Eggnog **SEASONAL**
Eggnog vanilla cake with cinnamon eggnog frosting ***SEASONAL ONLY*** NOV-JAN
$21.00
Fluffernutter
Vanilla cake with whipped peanut butter filling, marshmallow frosting topped with peanuts
$21.00
Funnel Cake
Vanilla cake with cinnamon spiced frosting topped with funnel cake
$21.00
German Chocolate
Chocolate cake topped with chocolate frosting and coconut pecan filling
$22.00
Gingerbread **SEASONAL**
Gingerbread cake topped with spiced cream cheese frosting NOV-JAN
$21.00
Hot Cocoa
Chocolate cake topped with whipped marshmallow frosting
$21.00
Hot Fudge Lava Sundae
Chocolate cake filled with fudge topped with whipped cream frosting and sprinkles
$21.00
Kit Kat®
Chocolate cake topped with caramel Kit Kat® crumble frosting
$21.00
Lemon Blueberry
Fresh blueberry and lemon cake topped with blueberry frosting ***SEASONAL ONLY*** May-AUG
$22.00
Maple Pecan Pancake
Vanilla cinnamon cake with maple pecan frosting topped with mini pancakes and real maple syrup
$22.00
Mint cookie
Chocolate cake with cookie bits topped with mint chocolate buttercream
$20.00
Mint chocolate
Chocolate cake topped with mint chocolate buttercream and candy pieces
$20.00
Nutella
Vanilla cake with Nutella Frosting
$21.00
Nutella Smores
Chocolate cake filled with Nutella topped with marshmallow and graham crackers
$21.00
Nutter Butter
Double chocolate cake filled with peanut butter with Nutter butter whipped frosting
$21.00
Peanut Butter Lover
Peanut butter cake filled with peanut butter fudge and peanut butter buttercream
$21.00
Peanut Butter White Chocolate
Vanilla cake topped with peanut butter buttercream and white chocolate flakes
$21.00
PB&J
Vanilla cake filled with grape jelly topped with whipped peanut butter frosting
$21.00
Peppermint Mocha
Peppermint mocha cake with chocolate frosting and espresso chocolate swirl
$21.00
Pineapple Coconut
Pineapple cake topped with pineapple coconut frosting**SEASONAL JUN-SEPT
$21.00
POPTART
Vanilla cake filled with strawberry preserves topped with fresh strawberry buttercream
$21.00
Pumpkin Caramel **SEASONAL
Pumpkin spice cake topped with caramel buttercream **SEASONAL SEPT-NOV
$20.00
Pumpkin Maple Pecan **SEASONAL
Pumpkin spice cake topped with maple pecan buttercream **SEASONAL SEPT-NOV
$21.00
Pumpkin Espresso Chip
Pumpkin spice cake topped with pumpkin espresso buttercream *SEASONAL*
$21.00
Pumpkin Mocha
Mocha chocolate cake topped with pumpkin buttercream
$20.00
Pumpkin Spice **SEASONAL
Pumpkin spice cake topped with cinnamon cream cheese frosting *refrigeration needed **SEASONAL SEPT-NOV
$21.00
Red Velvet
Red Velvet cake with cream cheese frosting. PER DOZEN ONLY
$40.00
Salted Caramel Mocha
Chocolate mocha cake with salted caramel frosting topped with sea salt
$21.00
Snickerdoodle
Vanilla cinnamon cupcake with cinnamon sugar cream cheese frosting
$21.00
S'mores
Chocolate cake filled with marshmallow(option), topped with chocolate ganache and marshmallow frosting
$21.00
Tiramisu
Vanilla cake soaked in coffee topped with espresso mascarpone whipped cream
$21.00
Toffee Caramel
Vanilla cake topped with chocolate caramel buttercream and toffee bits
$20.00
Toffee Crunch
Chocolate cake topped with chocolate dipped caramel frosting & crunchy toffee bits
$21.00
Turtle
Vanilla cake with chocolate caramel frosting topped with pecans
$21.00
Twix®
Chocolate cake topped with whipped caramel frosting
$20.00
Vanilla Cinnamon
Cinnamon vanilla cake with caramel frosting and caramel swirl
$21.00
White Chocolate Raspberry
Vanilla cake with raspberry filling topped with white chocolate cream cheese frosting *refrigeration needed
$21.00
White Mocha Latte
Vanilla cake topped with coffee buttercream and white chocolate flakes
$20.00
Pumpkin Cookie Dough **SEASONAL
Pumpkin spice cake topped with cookie dough buttercream and edible cookie dough **SEASONAL SEPT-NOV
$21.00 - Unavailable
White Chocolate Pumpkin **SEASONAL ONLY**
White chocolate cake topped with pumpkin spice frosting AVAILABLE SEPT-NOV
$21.00 - Unavailable
Hot Cocoa Bombs
Chocolate balls containing marshmallows, cocoa mix, and flavor choices. Sold individually or 4 per box. **36 hour notice for order freshness
Regular size Cocoa Bombs
Original flavor. Sold individually or 4 for $21
$6.00
Snickerdoodle
Hot coca mix with cinnamon and marshmallows inside a vanilla shell topped with cinnamon sugar
$6.00
Vanilla Caramel
Hot cocoa mix with caramel and marshmallows in a vanilla shell
$6.00
Salted Caramel
Hot cocoa mix with caramel and marshmallows in a chocolate shell topped with salted caramel
$6.00
Cookies & Cream
Hot cocoa mix with marshmallows in a cookies and cream shell
$6.00
Vanilla Chocolate Almond
Hot cocoa mix with marshmallows in a almond vanilla shell topped with chocolate and caramel
$6.00
Toffee
Hot cocoa mix with heath bar crumbles and marshmallow in a chocolate shell
$6.00
Espresso
Hot cocoa mix with instant espresso and marshmallows inside in an espresso chocolate shell
$6.00
Peppermint
Hot cocoa mix with peppermint pieces and marshmallows in a chocolate shell
$6.00
Fluffer Nutter Butter
hot chocolate powder, marshmallows, peanut butter chips, peanut butter and marshmallow sauce with Nutter Butter cookie
$6.00
Vanilla Cinnamon
Cinnamon hot cocoa and marshmallows in a vanilla shell
$6.00
Pumpkin Spice
Pumpkin spice mixed with hot cocoa mix in a chocolate shell
$6.00
Hazelnut
Hazelnut hot cocoa mix with marshmallows in a vanilla chocolate shell
$6.00
PB Chocolate
Peanut butter chocolate flavored cocoa with marshmallows in a chocolate peanut butter shell
$6.00
Lucky charms
hot cocoa mix with lucky charms marshmallows in a chocolate shell
$6.00
Covered oreos
Choose flavor coating and design
Coated Oreos
Coated with color choice and sprinkles $40 per dozen. Individually wrapped. No sticks
$40.00
Cake Pops
Cake Pops
Vanilla or Chocolate cake coated with chocolate or vanilla. Colors customizable. Sold individually. Quantity discounts available
$4.00
Personalized cake pops
Prices based on design complexity. Please contact for more details.
$4.00
Covered Pretzel Rods
Half dozen $18 Dozen $36 Choice of any toppings
Pretzel Rods
Personalized for any occasion. Chocolate, vanilla, or caramel covered. $36 per dozen
$3.00
Smash Cakes
Custom Smash cakes
Vanilla or chocolate 6in 2 layer celebration cake. Prices vary on design complexity. Starting at $35
$0.00
Cakesicles
Cakesicles are just like cake pops but even bigger and shaped like popsicles. If you are a cake pop lover then you will absolutely love these cakesicles, with that same yummy cake filling and chocolate shell on the outside
Cakesicles
Chocolate or vanilla cake with choice of shell coating flavor/color.
$4.50
Covered Rice Crispy Treats
Marshmallow crispy bars coated and customized. Individually wrapped
Covered rice crispy
Coated with choice of flavor and design. Individually wrapped
$4.00
Cakes
Pre-order only. At least 36 hours notice for orders. We make all products from scratch per order. Prices may fluctuate on flavor & design complexity. Please email us with special requests. the1withthecupcakes@gmail.com
6in cake
3 layer. choice of cake flavor and design.Prices may fluctuate on flavor & design complexity. Additional charge for filling and props
$0.00
8in cake
3 layer. choice of cake flavor and design Prices may fluctuate on flavor & design complexity. Additional charge for filling and props
$0.00
